NFL · Draft What If

What If the Tennessee Titans Drafted Randy Moss?

Tennessee chose Kevin Dyson five picks before Minnesota selected Randy Moss in 1998. What happens if Steve McNair, Eddie George and Moss spend their primes together in Nashville?

By Patrick Wise25 min readPremium FeatureSeptember 21, 2026
What If the Tennessee Titans Drafted Randy Moss?

Tennessee passed on Randy Moss in 1998. In this alternate history, pairing Moss with Steve McNair and Eddie George turns the Titans into the NFL’s defining dynasty of the early 2000s and changes how the league views mobile quarterbacks.

01

THE NAME ON THE CARD

On April 18, 1998, the franchise was still called the Tennessee Oilers. Steve McNair was 25 years old. Eddie George was 24. Jeff Fisher was entering his fourth full season as head coach, and the organization held the 16th selection in an NFL Draft that had already produced Peyton Manning, Ryan Leaf, Charles Woodson and Fred Taylor before Tennessee went on the clock. In real history, Tennessee selected Utah wide receiver Kevin Dyson. Five selections later, Minnesota took Randy Moss at No. 21. Dyson developed into a useful NFL receiver, but Moss immediately became one of the league's most difficult offensive players to defend. The reasons Moss fell were well known. NFL teams had concerns about incidents from his past and questioned whether they wanted to commit a first-round pick to him. The football evaluation was much easier. Moss had rare speed, size, ball skills and the ability to score from anywhere on the field. Tennessee decides the talent is worth the risk. Paul Tagliabue walks to the podium. The Tennessee Oilers select Randy Moss. Minnesota never gets its chance.

02

WHAT TENNESSEE ALREADY HAD

The 1998 Oilers did not need Moss to rescue them. They needed him to complete something that was already being built. McNair had become the full-time starting quarterback. George was entering his third season after rushing for more than 1,300 yards in each of his first two years. Frank Wycheck had developed into a dependable tight end, Derrick Mason was beginning his second NFL season, and Tennessee had signed veteran receiver Yancey Thigpen. The real 1998 Oilers finished 8-8. McNair passed for 3,228 yards and also rushed for 559. George carried the ball 348 times for 1,294 yards, but his 3.7 yards per carry reflected how frequently defenses could concentrate on Tennessee's running game. Moss changes that problem before his first NFL snap. If a safety moves closer to George, McNair can attack vertically. If the safety stays deep, George has one fewer defender involved near the line of scrimmage. Wycheck gets more room underneath, while Thigpen and Mason are no longer receiving the secondary's first attention. Fisher does not abandon the running game. He finally has a passing threat capable of making defenses pay for focusing too heavily on it.

03

1998PREMIUM

Continue this timeline

This section is available to Sports Rewritten members. Checking your membership access…

View Membership
04

JEVON KEARSE NEVER MAKES IT TO TENNESSEEPREMIUM

Member-only section.

05

THE REST OF THE 1999 CLASSPREMIUM

Member-only section.

06

NASHVILLE FINALLY GETS THE TEAM IT WAS WAITING FORPREMIUM

Member-only section.

07

McNAIR'S BACKPREMIUM

Member-only section.

08

THE FIRST ST. LOUIS GAMEPREMIUM

Member-only section.

09

A PLAY THAT NEVER HAPPENSPREMIUM

Member-only section.

10

JACKSONVILLEPREMIUM

Member-only section.

11

SUPER BOWL XXXIVPREMIUM

Member-only section.

12

THE LAST PICK OF THE FIRST ROUNDPREMIUM

Member-only section.

13

McNAIR GETS MORE OF THE OFFENSEPREMIUM

Member-only section.

14

BALTIMOREPREMIUM

Member-only section.

15

SUPER BOWL XXXVPREMIUM

Member-only section.

16

RUDI JOHNSONPREMIUM

Member-only section.

17

2001PREMIUM

Member-only section.

18

NEW ENGLANDPREMIUM

Member-only section.

19

SUPER BOWL XXXVIPREMIUM

Member-only section.

20

WHAT THREE TITLES CHANGEPREMIUM

Member-only section.

21

2002PREMIUM

Member-only section.

22

2003PREMIUM

Member-only section.

23

THE BILL COMES DUEPREMIUM

Member-only section.

24

VETERANS START CALLINGPREMIUM

Member-only section.

25

2005PREMIUM

Member-only section.

26

SUPER BOWL XLPREMIUM

Member-only section.

27

THE CAREERS THAT COME OUT OF ITPREMIUM

Member-only section.

28

DERRICK MASON'S CAREER DOES NOT SHRINKPREMIUM

Member-only section.

29

JEFF FISHERPREMIUM

Member-only section.

30

THE CHAMPIONSHIPS TENNESSEE TAKES FROM OTHER TEAMSPREMIUM

Member-only section.

31

TENNESSEE HAS NO REASON TO DRAFT VINCE YOUNGPREMIUM

Member-only section.

32

VINCE YOUNG GOES HOMEPREMIUM

Member-only section.

33

BUILDING THE OFFENSE AROUND THE QUARTERBACKPREMIUM

Member-only section.

34

THE COPYCAT LEAGUE RESPONDSPREMIUM

Member-only section.

35

THE NEXT GENERATIONPREMIUM

Member-only section.

36

FIVE PICKSPREMIUM

Member-only section.

SPORTS REWRITTEN MEMBERSHIP

Go deeper into the multiverse.

Unlock every premium timeline with a Sports Rewritten membership.

View Membership

MORE TIMELINES

Keep rewriting history

NFL · Draft What If

What If the Colts Traded John Elway to the Chargers?

The Chargers nearly had the draft capital to pry John Elway away from Baltimore in 1983. In this timeline they finally pay the price, sending three first-round picks and setting off a chain reaction that reshapes the Colts, Chargers, Cowboys, Vikings, Steelers and 49ers.

21 min read
MLB · Season What If

What If the 1994 MLB Strike Never Happened?

The 1994 strike erased a pennant race, a World Series, statistical chases and the best Expos team ever. Sports Rewritten finishes the season, crowns a champion and follows the consequences through Montreal, New York and the future of Major League Baseball.

19 min read
Boxing · Career What If

What If Mike Tyson Never Went to Prison?

Mike Tyson lost three prime years while heavyweight boxing transformed around him. In this Sports Rewritten timeline, he stays active, avenges Buster Douglas, collides with Holyfield, Bowe and Lewis, builds a sneaker and gaming empire, and changes how long boxing remains at the center of American sports culture.

17 min read

THE DISCUSSION

Comments

0 approved

No approved comments yet. Start the conversation.

Join the discussion

Comments are reviewed before they appear publicly. You must be signed in to comment.

Sign in or create a reader account to join the discussion.